Mohamed Salah has firmly etched his name into Liverpool’s rich footballing history as one of the defining figures of the club’s modern era. Joining the Reds from AS Roma in 2017, the Egyptian winger quickly evolved into a relentless goal machine. Over the years, Salah has shattered long-standing records and amassed a collection of personal and team honours — all while maintaining elite performance levels deep into his 30s.
As of April 2025, Salah stands on the brink of even greater legacy. Mohamed Salah now finds himself just behind the legendary Ian Rush and Roger Hunt on Liverpool’s all-time top scorers list — a clear reflection of his extraordinary consistency and goal-scoring ability. With every game, he draws nearer to claiming the title of the club’s all-time leading goal scorer, further cementing his legacy as one of the greatest to ever wear the iconic red shirt. With his consistent form and remarkable scoring rate, the Egyptian forward is within striking distance of overtaking both and securing his place among the Reds’ most prolific finishers. On a broader scale, he also remains on course to cement his name among the top three scorers in Premier League history — a testament to his longevity and elite status in English football.
Despite Salah’s remarkable success in a Liverpool shirt — Premier League titles, Champions League glory, and a mountain of goals — not everyone is ready to crown him the greatest in the club’s storied history. The debate over where he stands among the Reds’ legends is still very much alive.
Former Liverpool striker Peter Crouch recently entered the discussion, offering his personal list of the club’s all-time icons. His rankings added fuel to the conversation, showing just how fiercely competitive and subjective the legacy of greatness at Anfield can be. For those exploring football analysis and opportunities beyond the pitch, including smart predictions and bonus offers, Melbet Nigeria offers a platform worth checking out. Keep reading to the end for an exclusive treat — a special promo code!
Salah’s Journey at Anfield
The Egyptian winger made an immediate impact, scoring 32 league goals in his debut Premier League season. His incredible performance catapulted him to the forefront of European football, solidifying his reputation as one of the most formidable attackers on the continent. Over time, his role evolved—while he remained a constant threat in front of goal, he also took on more responsibility as a leader within the squad.
Salah’s work ethic, sharp decision-making, and relentless desire to improve have ensured his relevance across different phases of his career. At 32, he remains Liverpool’s main source of goals and creativity. With 184 Premier League goals — 182 of them for Liverpool — he is closing in on second-placed Roger Hunt in the club’s scoring history.
Peter Crouch’s View: Gerrard and Dalglish Ranked Higher
In a recent episode of his podcast, Peter Crouch acknowledged Salah’s extraordinary output but suggested that the title of “Liverpool’s greatest player” still belongs to others. He argued that being a top goalscorer is not the same as being the best overall player. “Football isn’t just about scoring goals,” Crouch said. “I’ve not seen Mo Salah control a game the way Steven Gerrard did.”
Crouch highlighted Gerrard’s ability to influence matches from midfield and contribute across all areas of the pitch. In his view, that broader impact gives the former captain an edge over Salah, despite the difference in numbers. He also brought up Kenny Dalglish—despite not seeing him play live — as another name who deserves to be mentioned before Salah in the conversation about all-time greats.
Salah’s Place in Liverpool’s All-Time Rankings
While Crouch’s comments have generated debate, they reflect a common dilemma in football analysis: how to weigh statistics against influence. Salah’s scoring record is historic, and he remains one of Liverpool’s most dependable performers. Yet players like Gerrard and Dalglish are remembered for defining eras and shaping the club’s identity on and off the pitch.
Salah may eventually surpass Hunt in goals, but Ian Rush’s record of 339 goals remains distant.
Melbet Nigeria: Smart Choices for Football Fans
Football fans looking to turn their knowledge into winnings can explore options with Melbet Nigeria. With a user-friendly interface and a wide range of sports events, the platform offers practical tools for making informed choices.
By using the promo code MELGIFT during account registration, new users can access an enhanced welcome bonus, giving them a stronger start to their betting journey. Additionally, Melbet partners have the opportunity to receive customized promo codes that can be used in targeted marketing campaigns, driving more sign-ups and engagement with tailored offers that resonate with their audience.
Conclusion
Peter Crouch’s take on the Salah debate has reignited long-standing conversations about what makes a footballer truly great. While statistics like goals and assists are easy to measure, influence, leadership, and game intelligence often tell a different story.
For many fans, Salah’s numbers alone place him in the top tier of Liverpool legends. However, Crouch’s perspective reminds us that greatness in football is multidimensional. Whether it’s Gerrard’s command in midfield or Dalglish’s legacy as both player and manager, different qualities shape the memory of legends.
Ultimately, comparing players across different generations is never straightforward. What’s undeniable is that Mohamed Salah has already secured his legacy — and fans will continue to debate his place in Liverpool’s history for years to come.
Article updated 34 minutes ago. Content is written and modified by multiple authors.
